Israel’s Bold Plan: Who Will Govern Gaza After Hamas? (Latest Update 2025)
A senior Israeli diplomat has stated that neither Israel nor Hamas will govern Gaza after the war, reaffirming that Israel has no interest in ruling the territory. Instead, Israel is working closely with allies, particularly the U.S., to determine the region’s future. The conflict recently escalated after a failed ceasefire, leaving uncertainty over who will take control once Hamas is removed. President Donald Trump has proposed relocating Gaza’s 2 million residents and redeveloping the area, an idea praised by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu but widely condemned in the Arab world.
Meanwhile, Egypt and the Arab League have suggested placing Gaza under an independent Palestinian committee before transferring control to the Palestinian Authority (PA), a plan supported by Hamas but rejected by Israel. The war, which began on October 7, 2023, has resulted in over 50,000 Palestinian and 1,600 Israeli deaths, with dozens of hostages still held by Hamas. Israel remains committed to dismantling Hamas, securing its hostages, and ensuring Gaza never again poses a threat. However, Hamas insists that only Palestinians should determine their own future, calling for democratic elections and an independent state.
With no clear agreement among international powers, Gaza’s fate remains a pressing and unresolved issue.
Israel’s Bold Plan: Who Will Govern Gaza After Hamas? (Latest Update 2025)
A senior Israeli official has made it clear that neither Israel nor Hamas will govern Gaza once the conflict ends. Tsach Saar, Israel’s Deputy Consul General in New York, told Newsweek that while removing Hamas from power is essential, Israel has no plans to take control of the territory. Instead, Israel is collaborating with allies like the U.S. to explore alternatives for Gaza’s future governance.
War Resumes as Truce Collapses
After a temporary ceasefire broke down, Israel resumed its military campaign in Gaza. Both sides blame each other for the collapse of the truce, but the larger question remains unresolved: Who will govern Gaza if Hamas is no longer in charge?
U.S. Proposal Sparks Outrage
Former U.S. President Donald Trump stirred controversy by suggesting the relocation of Gaza’s 2 million residents to other countries and redeveloping the area for real estate. Though Trump clarified that any relocation would be voluntary, the idea drew sharp criticism across the Arab world. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu praised the proposal as “the first good idea I’ve heard,” but the backlash underscored deep divisions over Gaza’s fate.
Arab League’s Alternative Plan
Egypt and the Arab League proposed a different approach: temporarily transferring Gaza’s administration to an independent Palestinian committee before handing control to the Palestinian Authority (PA), which currently governs parts of the West Bank. While Hamas and the PA support this plan, Israel rejects it, expressing distrust in the PA’s ability to manage Gaza securely.
Human Toll and Hostage Crisis
Since the war began on October 7, 2023, over 50,000 Palestinians and 1,600 Israelis have been killed. Hamas initially took 251 hostages during its surprise attack; around 59 remain captive, including five Americans. Israel’s primary goals are dismantling Hamas, freeing all hostages, and ensuring Gaza cannot pose a future threat.
Failed Ceasefire and Stalled Talks
A previous truce led to the release of some hostages and Palestinian prisoners but fell apart when negotiations stalled. Israel claims Hamas rejected a U.S.-backed extension, while Hamas insists it adhered to the original agreement. The breakdown highlights the deep mistrust between the two sides and complicates efforts to revive diplomacy.
Gaza’s Governance Dilemma
Despite heavy losses, Hamas still holds parts of Gaza, and Israel’s military operations continue. Saar emphasized that Israel’s immediate focus is defeating Hamas and rescuing hostages but acknowledged that establishing stable post-war leadership remains a challenge. He hinted at the possibility of a temporary administration taking over but provided no specifics.
Hamas, meanwhile, insists that Palestinians alone should decide their future. Spokesperson Basem Naim accused Israel and Trump of attempting to displace Palestinians, instead calling for an independent Palestinian state through democratic elections.
No Clear Path Forward
The international community remains divided. The U.S. and Israel seek solutions that exclude Hamas, while Arab nations push for Palestinian-led governance. With no consensus in sight, Gaza’s future hangs in the balance. Civilians continue to bear the brunt of the violence, with aid groups warning of catastrophic humanitarian conditions.
As the war drags on, the stakes grow higher. Israel faces pressure to articulate a realistic plan for Gaza, while Hamas seeks to retain influence despite its weakening grip. For now, the territory’s fate—and the prospect of lasting peace—remains uncertain, leaving millions in limbo amid the devastation of prolonged conflict.
Key Points:
- Israel refuses to govern Gaza post-war but insists Hamas cannot remain in power.
- Trump’s relocation proposal and Egypt’s PA-led plan both face significant obstacles.
- Civilian casualties and the hostage crisis complicate diplomatic efforts.
- No agreement exists on who should lead Gaza, prolonging the humanitarian crisis.
The world watches as leaders struggle to answer a critical question: How can Gaza rebuild without repeating the cycles of violence that have shaped its past?